DeafPagers.com Blog header image 1

Comparing the Sidekick II, 3, and iD

May 7th, 2007 · 43 Comments

The Sidekick series continues to be the most popular wireless device within the deaf community. Blog readers, and prospective purchasers have asked the blog editor, Deafpagers.com Sales representatives, and even the Deafpagers.com support department a lot of questions regarding the Sidekick. One of the most common questions asked is: “Which model is better?” The answer is: All Sidekick devices are good purchases. It just depends on what features you need. You should carefully select the right one for your needs. For example, will you heavily use the SK3’s built in camera? Or will you make use of the SK3’s music player? You will also need to decide if you ever will consider using the SK3’s Bluetooth technology? The reason we ask these questions of you is because, some users really do not need to purchase the top of the line Sidekick, which currently is the Sidekick 3.

We have developed a comparison chart (below) for you to make your own comparisons of the different features among the Sidekick line, to help you decide what you really want, and it may help you realize what you really do not need. If you have any questions or find any errors, just leave a comment, and we will respond.

Features
Sidekick
II
Sidekick
3
Sidekick
ID
 
Instant messagin Yes - AIM and Yahoo Yes - AIM, Yahoo, and MSN Yes - AIM, Yahoo, and MSN
Built in Camera Yes - VGA Yes - 1.3 megapixel No
Bluetooth No Yes - Bluetooth 1.2

No

MP3 player No Yes No
mini-SD card slot No Yes - up to 2GB No
Removal rechargeable battery No Yes - 1500 mAh Yes (?)
Keyboard QWERTY (Rubber) QWERTY (Solid) QWERTY (Solid)
Text messaging (SMS) Yes - Unlimited with Data only plan Yes - Unlimited with Data only plan Yes - Unlimited with Data only plan
Web Browsing Real web browsing Real web browsing Real web browsing
Size 5.1 by 2.6 by 0.9 inches 5.1 by 2.3 by 0.8 inches 5.12 x 2.48 x 0.87 inches
Display 65,000 colors
240×160 pixel resolution
65,000 colors
240×160 pixel resolution
65,000 colors
240×160 pixel resolution
Weight 6.5 ounces 6.7 ounces 6.2 ounces
Navigation Rollaway small trackball small trackball
Relay Service IP-Relay and i711 IP-Relay and i711 IP-Relay and i711
Hearing
Aid Compatible
(M3 or M4)
No No No
TTY Yes - Option offered by i711 Yes - Option offered by i711 Yes - Option offered by i711
Vibrator Yes - Email, SMS, IM, and Phone Yes - Email, SMS, IM, and Phone Yes - Email, SMS, IM, and Phone
Retial Price: Discontinued $299.99 $149.99

Tags: Wireless Device Reviews · Wireless Devices Issues

43 responses so far ↓

  • 1 red // May 7, 2007 at 2:07 pm

    i would have choosen sidekick ID if they have built in camera

  • 2 ToddE // May 7, 2007 at 6:32 pm

    How come there was no discussion of network speeds? i.e., gprs, edge, etc.? I would think each device’s maximum network speed would be a factor in such purchase decisions.

  • 3 Dianrez // May 7, 2007 at 11:01 pm

    The SK2 had a special price to the deaf community of $149.99 after rebates and a data plan of $29.99 per month. Some retailers still have remaining SK2’s available.

    Are there going to be rebates or price reductions on the other two models, and are the monthly data plans the same price for all?

    These are factors that also help in deciding between which model.

  • 4 nichole brooks // May 9, 2007 at 5:03 pm

    hello this is nichole how that i already got bad creidt on this but i couldnt get sidekick id but i really need this so bad and i will going to love it but i cant wait for this for a long time but it hard for me to get and order but i dont know when i am going to get it it been a 5 year now dang i like that so i didnt know it cost 99.00 sale i expect this so email me asap when u get this alright god bless u!

  • 5 nichole brooks // May 9, 2007 at 5:08 pm

    so one thing is iam hard of hearing and i really need this so bad but i dont like using my sprint cell phone but it still cut off i didnt pay the phone cuz too much bill i rather low monthly u know what im say so i want this sidekick id so i can chatting with my deaf friend too im tired of using my mom computer i want my own one that all if i get sidekick id i will be satifated abt it (smile).

  • 6 JOhanna // May 21, 2007 at 3:58 am

    There are sidekick ID no have Built in Camera…you can see there list information. I rather stay with my sidekick 3 have camera. Sidekick ID dont have camera…..

  • 7 brett voss // May 21, 2007 at 4:44 am

    Hi I had use sk2 since march 2001 or 2002 not sure and those sk2 rubber cover keyboard pad cover do you have someone sell it or order as I looked the website to order but it doesn’t have it why ?? Seems they had to buy new sk2 mine it work great just the letter rubber keyboard few worn out can you give me website or number to call want to order cover label ok if don’t understand email me thank you and have a great day , Brett

  • 8 Pamela K // May 21, 2007 at 6:31 am

    I like Sidekick II much better than Sidekick 3 and Sidekick Id Why I don’t like the small ball that like a mouse it a waste of time. Beside there are plenty of still good used Sidekick II on E Bay all you need to do is transfer your sim card onto another Sidekick II and it works fine I do not even like Blackberry because not good vibration like Sidekicks so I do wish they would remake Sidekick II as it is a very good device better than any device I ve ever seen

  • 9 PsYcHoWiLLiE // May 21, 2007 at 6:50 am

    SIDEKICK3 is an excellent pager that offer anythings you need in ONE pager so I really don’t understand @ all why SideKick ID came outta da market as it seem like it is da same version of SideKick2……….

  • 10 Steve DeRocher // May 21, 2007 at 7:03 am

    Nicole Brooks!! If ya wantto buy new sk3 or ID therefore ya can be purchase t-mobile without credit check for make a contract however T-mobile sell 2 different price to purchase sk3 without contract which doesn’t require credit check and to contract. They sell at the full price of without contract then ya can purchase prepaid account to able use service on the sk3 for prepaid will charge ya one dollar a day for all of sk3 catalog to use it. Ya all need to buy 15, 25, 50, 100 dollars at any store to credit the sk3 to keep service on till run out of the fund then purchase more prepaid. So T-mobile usually sell 2 different price for contract will sell u low price of their sale. Secondary thing is if ya can’t afford to buy a new sk3 then go look up your local craigslist.org classfield under electronic catalog to look for used sk3 and get a prepaid. Its better than use any of crap regular cellulars at the cost. Here the Link ya may go look at craigslist.org

    Happy hunting to find sk3 for your reasonable affordable and enjoy it :)

  • 11 Janella // May 21, 2007 at 8:06 am

    I dont like black berry very well because black berry 7290 i do use email and text message but i cant use ip relay it make me lot of frustional and not worth it i pay per month every month $39.95per month for nothing just use 2 of them that all watse of my money and i do use sk 1 i cant read it bec of little black words so i sell out so i do know i have been with t mobile for 3 contract with this company no help at all i still look for other kind of cell phone etc to make all work and worth money period okay thank you janella

  • 12 admin // May 21, 2007 at 9:34 am

    The Sidekick iD would be perfect for those people who want to be able to bring it to their workplace. Most Federal agencies here in DC have banned employees from bringing in cellphones with a built-in camera including the SK 2 and 3.

  • 13 nancy jamison // May 21, 2007 at 11:08 am

    hi sir how cost sidkick 3 and let me know have anice day nancy

  • 14 ANDRA // May 21, 2007 at 11:42 am

    I ENJOY SIDEKICK 2 BUT HEARD SK 3 BETTER AND WEIGH LIGHTER COOL BUT ONE THING ABT SK 1,2,3 THE FONT ARE VERY SMALL CAN’T CHANGE FONT SIZE LIKE BLACKBERRY .IT WUD BE NICE IF CAN CHANGE FONT SIZES FOR US CAN READ CLEAR. IT’S FUSTRATED FOR ME ESPECIALLY NUMBERS. I THINK U WILL GET BETTER SELLING IF FONT SIZES ADDED LIKE COMPUTER.

  • 15 Sue // May 21, 2007 at 4:51 pm

    i not know sk2 had yahoo instant messenger. how i get it? also rubber keypad worn, how get new one? love my sk2. how i live without!!! thanks

  • 16 Simone (Sims) // May 22, 2007 at 12:50 pm

    Hiya,

    I had two Sk2 n Sk3 but My sk2 broken Screen. I wud buy it anytime. I not need sell sk2. I’m keepin’ my two sk 2 n 3. Sk2 little betta than sk3 why bec Sk2’s very strong Vibrate betta than Sk3. Sk3’s Battery very easy Low so quick ! It’s So dumb.

    Anyway, Sk ID’s new, look good n different color. but one thing Sk ID haven’t Camera. Anyone need Sk ID need Camera. Compnay must make Camera put Sk ID! am i correct?

    I heard tha sidekick 4 soon comin’? Thank.

  • 17 Bethie // May 22, 2007 at 2:18 pm

    Hiya what’s up everybody? Me? GREAT!!! I really loved my SK3 because of light weigh, taking picture in good image size, I don’t mind the mouse ball because I got used to it, but anyway one problem with the font size that make it hard to read! Can one of you at T-mobile Company able to update new sizes for the fonts to make our life easier! Please lemme know and your appricate!

  • 18 debby // May 22, 2007 at 9:02 pm

    WEll I agree that side kick id is good for work place where camera built in pagers are not allowed but everybody loves to have pagers with camera built in. Why can’t id pagers have two options one with camera built in and other without? I still use side kick 1 and have not purchased new one yet cuz it still works fine. I have camera I can carry to anywhere, so why do I need camera built in pagers?

  • 19 brenda loving // May 23, 2007 at 3:54 am

    hello this is brenda loving i was try to fill out if i could get sk3 id let me know if i could get free or pay thank s

  • 20 patricia r. clincy // May 23, 2007 at 1:58 pm

    I say what ‘ s up if you could get get free for deaf pager ? thank you pat.

  • 21 nichole brooks // May 24, 2007 at 8:04 pm

    hey i just got ur message and i was suprise that u respone it wow so oh well im looking for it right now thank then! i will go look at craigslist org anyway.

  • 22 DONNA // May 31, 2007 at 5:26 am

    HI…MY OPTION THAT SIDEKICK3 IS BETTER THAN SK2 OR SIDEKICK ID BECAUSE SIDEKICK ID IS TOO PLAIN JUST TOO FANCY COLOR BUT NOT INCLUDE CAMERA AND STILL THE PRICE 29.95 MONTHLY.. I THINK TOO MUCH FOR PAYMENT ON SIDEKICK ID ..BUT SK3 EVERYTHING INSIDE THAT HAVE CAMERA,VIDEO,EMAIL,WEBSITE,PHONE,RELAY,TEXT,VARIETY ON A LISTS….AND 29.95 WAS PERFECT ….MY OPTION YOU SHOULD REDUCE THE PRICE EVERY MONTHLY FOR SIDEKICK ID DOWN TO 22.95 TO 24.95 SOMETHING LIKE THAT MAKE PEOPLE SATISFIED WITH THE PRICE..I THINK IT WAS NICE SIDEKICK ID BUT WITH PRICE … I DONT THINK SO .. RATHER SK3 …. I DO HAVE SK3 MYSELF…
    ~G*I*R*A*F*F*E

  • 23 John Mason // Jun 8, 2007 at 6:54 am

    Everybody are entitled to have their opinion about Sidekicks. I am SK2 owner and I am satisfied with it. There are difference between the “wants” and “needs”. I am sure there are alot of deaf who “wants” better pager to be advanced in technology. I know some guys and gals still have the original Sidekick (in black and white!) and they’re satified as long they still get emails. Most of them would rather wait to get new one after their pagers croaked/died/terminated. When you buy SK3 or SKid, I hope you’re satisfied what you NEED. For those are “Must Have” better be satisfied what they WANT. The seller doesn’t care which you buy but they see dollar signs! Ka-ching! (sound from the old cash register) Oh, one more thing, if you are in the movie theater, please turn the deaf pagers completely off! Cheers!

  • 24 admin // Jun 8, 2007 at 7:40 am

    John Mason. You said that dealer do not care?, in fact, Deafpagers.com and most thrid party dealers are not able to offer upgrades, Deafpagers.com refered customers to T-Mobile Store to purchase upgrade. They do not make profit on hardware. They profit from service. At Deafpagers.com store, some customers come in and ask for upgrade, I asked customers if their old devices work fine? Most of them said Yes, then I told them not need to buy upgrade, until the device is truely dead.
    Deafpagers.com retail salesperson.

  • 25 John Mason // Jun 8, 2007 at 8:23 am

    admin, I acknowledged that you do care since you are a dealer not seller. Your customers appreciate your advise on upgrade. You’re correct about T-mobile’s profitability from service but who is making profit from Sidekicks? Danger Inc. or distributors? Enough said, the main thing is customer’s satisfaction.

  • 26 holly // Jun 19, 2007 at 1:49 am

    i just wonder if i not have card c i just wonder i can use ordermoney i just wonder that all i am deaf i like see i never before

  • 27 Angelo // Jun 20, 2007 at 12:25 pm

    Id need very important for need camera need to be more proof to take pics for any reason in case. must have one for all deaf.

  • 28 Jim // Jun 22, 2007 at 11:31 am

    I have the Sidekick ID and like it quite a lot.
    I don’t like the resolution of the camera on the SK3 and don’t need Mp3 playback. The ID is a good, economical solution for my mobile communications needs.

  • 29 James Ambler // Jun 26, 2007 at 12:53 pm

    I want to know how much cost of sidekick 3 pager. but I do have netzero internt. will u let me know ok thank you. have nice day . by James Ambler

  • 30 Gail // Jun 26, 2007 at 4:56 pm

    Does the Sidekick ID have better coverage in certain areas where SK2/3 do not?

  • 31 Laura // Jul 9, 2007 at 11:14 pm

    i live in the dominican republic, but right now in miami for vacations, im dyinnng to get a sidekick. but i was told the internet conection and text messaging couldn’t be used were i live…:S plus i would have to pay to unlock it once i get to the D.R…
    does anyone know about this…!
    S.O.S
    Help Please!!!
    ladybuuge@hotmail.com

  • 32 jada // Jul 16, 2007 at 11:16 pm

    wut up i heard sidekick2’s were better than sk id’s well don’t listen 2 dat cause there not sk2’s r garbage ,trash,nada dam thing

  • 33 Elmore Frank Brown Jr // Aug 7, 2007 at 7:37 pm

    Hi, I have a side kick 3 I like it a lots it have everything on it but it did not have a live web cam video. I heard there are rumors about thr new sidekick 4 it I’d true? If they do have sidekick 4 what will I do with my sidekick3 I just bought it 6 month ago I do not want to wast my money. Can I trade my sidekick 3 to sidekick4 and you can sell or give the sidekick 3 for free who can not afford it. Thanks.

  • 34 Hawaii girl // Aug 8, 2007 at 10:33 am

    I heard that all new pagers will no longer to use built-in camera due to terriorists. That’s why new BB and SKid don’t have cameras. I still have my SK2 for a long time but rubber keyboard is bubble and it don’t bother me. When it brokes, I would buy SKid or other new pagers. Yes, I heard SK4 will come soon. Mahalo.

  • 35 Hawaii girl // Aug 8, 2007 at 6:15 pm

    Just found out that they have Sidekick Zante, LX, LE, Razr and Sch… (spell?). Hard to choose the best.

  • 36 eddie stevenson // Aug 26, 2007 at 2:35 pm

    I wish id had cam sure but if I can get for a $50 mail in rebate I say ok.

  • 37 GRETTA WILLIAMS // Aug 27, 2007 at 9:06 pm

    HI MY NAME IS GRETTA WILLIAMS FROM SAN ANTONIO,TX. I AM 37 YRS OLD DEAF HALF LITTLEBIT HOH. I FOUND DEAFOAGERS ONLINE AND JUST LOOK FOR SIDEKICK PAGERS IN MY DESKTOP. I AM SURPRISE ABT THAT IS NEW SIDEKICK ID. IT IS COOL! I DONT KNOW HOW MUCH ITS INVOLES WITH ITS THINGS! PLZ WRITE AND EMAIL ME ANYTIMES!

  • 38 TJ // Sep 2, 2007 at 7:52 pm

    I am looking forward to getting Sidekick 3 finally. But I’m very disappointed to see that none of the SK devices have hearing aid compatibility. I do NOT use phone, am too Deaf cannot hear. But if SK is marketed so much to Deaf with relay and tty, why not make it easier for HOH too? Sorry about that guys and hope they do something about that soon.

  • 39 rayricko cooper // Sep 24, 2007 at 6:47 am

    i was look there sidekick id how much? i like this sidekick id…..please send to me

  • 40 jacqueline // Sep 30, 2007 at 1:27 am

    hii everyone ,
    my name is jacqulein -deaf-18-4rm tsd- i live in memphis- my family are hearing just only me deaf that all..

    i would like knws how much cost this sk3 beacuse i like used sk3 email, crema, yim,aim, msn, anything i like sk3 than old sk2 beacuse sk2 has always promble till.. and computer.. i want sk3 now, make me chilli or out hang with friends beacuse i tired of my bro used my computer .. i felt tired of bro.. i want sk3 make me chilli my mom let me knw where she go .. any where fun ..

    pls tell em abt here aim is wildlovejohn37 or laughXlovexwif3
    thanks anyone deaf or hearing

  • 41 nathaniel cannon // Nov 20, 2007 at 11:54 am

    I WANT TO LOOK FOR SIDEKICK TWO OF PAGER USE BUY IT.

  • 42 melissa // Dec 15, 2007 at 5:48 pm

    hi i have the tmobile service, its not pre-paid. i got a really samsung phone threw them but really wanted a sidekick id so i went on ebay && got one, it works but the only problem im having is that my sim car when put into the sidekick id.. it wont show any numbers in my phone book, or anything like that. can any1 relate or help?

  • 43 New Sidekick iD // Jan 7, 2008 at 1:22 am

    […] and am surprised I missed this one. I searched DeafRead, and sure enough, there are iD reviews (1, 2). But that’s not why I’m […]

Leave a Comment